- #21 [fotheringay], 23-01-30 10:53
- #22 [myml], 23-01-30 21:13reply #20
The songs in the album are all the early songs of Bee Gees(1967 to 1968) . It is a (LP Compilation) of early Bee Gees According to Wikipedia information, for example, another song "Sinking Ships" is also from 1968. single release
Second, according to DISCOGS, this (LP, Compilation) was released in December 1968, and this song was Released March 1968. It is not known whether this is a (LP, Compilation) product of the later Bee Gees music. , I'm not sure - #23 [myml], 23-01-30 21:39reply #21
Stereo sound and monophonic sound are two different things and should not be confused. Before 1957, people had no choice. It was not until the appearance of stereo sound that people began to listen to stereo sound.
Whether you like monophonic or not is a personal matter -
- #24 [fotheringay], 23-01-31 05:07reply #22
The Bee Gees Golden Album was indeed a compilation album with songs from 1966-1968.
What I wasn't sure about Wiki was that they stated, as I quited, "so by standard practice at the time, it was not mixed to stereo." And again "The song was unavailable until 1990 when it was mixed in stereo for the first time and extended to 3:19 for inclusion on the Tales from the Brothers Gibb boxset. "
My argument not on whether it is a single or if included in a studio album but the point that it was indeed mixed as Stereo included in Bee Gees Golden Album. It was in 1968 so there was a stereo version well before 1990!!
Would you agree? - #25 [fotheringay], 23-01-31 05:16reply #23.
I ain't confused but it is wise to explain to other people who may have the experience.
Indeed it's a personal choice.
Change of subject and some most expensive records(Jazz, R&R and Folks) are actually mono releases, not only just because of the rarity but also the recording format some people preferred. - #26 [myml], 23-01-31 07:09reply #24
I'm also not sure if the 45 rpm I had at the time was stereo or not , because it's been long long time ago,
is The Singer Sang His Song in your Bee Gees Golden Album stereo? If it is a stereo language,
you can go to WIKI to modify the data, very easy I'm sure - #27 [myml], 23-01-31 07:14reply #25
I don't comment on other people's hobbies, I'm factual, discussing evidence, not personal preferences
Under common sense, which old technology is better than new technology?
It is enough to use monophonic and watch Charlie Chaplin movies,
why should there be any high-definition, why pursue the truth? ?
can you comment for that?? - #28 [myml], 23-01-31 08:53back to write #26
The Wiki says that the song (The Singer Sang His Song ) was only included in the "World Star Festival" LP before 1990. If your LP is really released in December 1968, the WIKI information is wrong, you can modify it
最後修改時間: 2023-01-31 08:54:45 - #29 [myml], 23-01-31 11:39reply #20
Wiki said last year that this song (The Singer Sang His Song) was only included in the "World Star Festival" LP before 1990,
I believe there may be a mistake, because I checked the WIKI again just now, and the relevant content no longer exists. At this moment, I want to prove whether there is no stereo version of The Singer Sang His Song before 1990. Please take a picture of the playing time of this song for clarification this point.. thank you ! - #30 [fotheringay], 23-02-01 00:01Now I think both Wiki and me are wrong.
Wiki was wrong that it was only ever appeared in "World Star Festival" LP before 1990.
I was wrong that it appeared as stereo version in the Gold Album. The whole album with all the prints that indicate that it is a stereo issue. Even the centre label of the record also has the two circles stereo mark and STEREO was printed.
However, I looked more carefully with the booklet though in Japanese and I think I have been mistaken. There is a little footnote which I read for the first time, with the writing on songs 1,3, 5, 6 on B Side and (The Singer Sang His Song) is song no. 5.
It has the Japanese writing of "モノラル " and it means "Mono recording".
Until further finding we can, at the time of writing, conclude that (The Singer Sang His Song) did appear more than one album and it was in Mono version until 1990.
最後修改時間: 2023-02-01 00:06:27 - #31 [myml], 23-02-01 00:49reply #30
I don't understand Japanese characters, I want to see the information behind your Bee Gees "Golden vinyl, the playing time of this song can prove whether it is a monophonic recording, I do have( Tales From The Brother's Gibb, A History In Song 1967-1990) CD, this song show me running time is 3 mins 19 second for stereo Recording,
can you show the whole picture to me if you have this vinyl ?? - #32 [fotheringay], 23-02-01 22:06reply #31
As per request.
BTW, I don't read Japanese either but I type in Mono and google with Japanese translation and it comes up the same writing as the one in the footnote.
最後修改時間: 2023-02-01 22:08:39 - #33 [myml], 23-02-01 22:36reply #32
I'm very sorry, what I need is the playing time information of The Singer Sang His Song, you don't need to zoom in for me to see, it will make you little bit harder , I have seen similar pictures on some websites, and they don't have what I want information, that's why I'm checking with you - #34 [myml], 23-02-01 22:42reply #32 again
once again , please don't zoom it to me , normal size is ok , thanks - #35 [myml], 23-02-02 01:26reply #32
hello....I saw it, because my desktop Computer can't display all the information, so I can't see the following information, thank you for your time anyway...
the mono version running time is 3 mins 08 second.
stereo version running time is 3 mins 19 second .
最後修改時間: 2023-02-02 01:29:56 - #36 [myml], 23-02-02 07:58
好歌不厭百回聽 Bee Gees 5
以下資料摘錄自Wikipedia / 及BEE GEES - IN OUR OWN TIME DVD 和私人收藏
及壹些個人意見,如資料有任何錯誤,請各網友修正…
Idea 是 Bee Gees 的第三張國際專輯。這張專輯於1968年9月發行,
全球銷量超過100萬張。此專輯裡的歌曲非常動聽,專輯中 I Started a Joke,
"I've Gotta Get a Message to You 這兩首熱門歌曲,我在這裡不多加介紹,
現在要跟大家分享的是專輯內其他數首我最比較喜愛的歌曲.
1) Kitty Can
Barry Gibb 說:“Kitty Can ”是由 Maurice 跟
LuLu 和我一起寫的,地點是我們三兄弟早期居住的住宅單位. LuLu 就是唱
To Sir With Love 那位女歌手,亦是 Maurice Gibb 的前度妻子.. - #37 [DC273], 23-02-02 11:21好嘢
- #38 [myml], 23-02-04 22:40reply #37
謝謝
最後修改時間: 2023-02-04 22:41:12 - #39 [DC273], 23-02-05 03:13听吓歌唔係好囉、有乜好拗吖
- #40 [myml], 23-02-05 21:33reply#39
是其是,非其非是也.. - 下一頁 (2 of 6)
- 返回 ...
I have their "Bee Gees First " in both Mono and Stereo first pressing. They have different sound for sure and you may think the Stereo version would be better.
Personally I prefer the Mono issue as it present better vocal in isolation.
It's very much like the Beatles.
George Martin had deliberately engineer the sound in Mono configuration in the first place for their early recording then remix to Stereo.
His argument was that stereo recording was still in the infantry and mono recording will give the vocal more beautiful and also playing drums with full ferocity. That was the sound the people loved at the time.
It was only after The White Album then better stereo mixing advanced in pace.